| It
is time to stand back and take a good look at Kashmir.
There has been a monumental tragedy. The figures keep
rising every day---50,000 dead, 70,000 injured, 2.5
million homeless, millions traumatized. These are
mere statistics. The real issue is: What next?
There are three distinct
phases in the wake of an earthquake. First, of course,
is first aid----the immediate rescue and relief stage,
when the trapped, the injured, the dead and the survivors
have to be cared for. Speed is of the essence, as
that alone saves lives. We are passing through this
stage today, with the entire nation coming together,
as never before in decades. Non- government organizations,
overseas Pakistanis and the international community
have pitched in. Huge administrative and organizational
failures occurred in the beginning, but slowly the
operation is beginning to come together. The dead
are being buried, medical aid is reaching the injured
and survivors are starting to get food and shelter.
Next is the interim
phase, which will cover the period till permanent
resettlement. This phase can go on for months or years,
depending upon national policy. The displaced will
be housed in tent villages, where interim arrangements
will be made for temporary
civic and social services. Ample funds and supplies
are pouring in to help with this phase.
The final phase is
one of reconstruction. It will involve a very broad
range of activities, from rebuilding the entire infrastructure
of roads, bridges, water, power, drainage, sewage,
etc; to reconstructing the civic and social services
like schools, hospitals, government offices, police
stations, courthouses, post offices, mosques, etc;
to creating an enabling environment for building new
homes; starting new businesses or resuming the ones
destroyed; and reconstructing their shattered lives.
The international community is already appraising
the costs involved, which will undoubtedly run into
several billion dollars.
The grave misfortune
is that Kashmiris have been totally excluded from
the first and interim phases and seem destined to
be sidelined in the major reconstruction phase as
well. It does not have to be that way.
In the first phase
thousands of well-wishers from outside Kashmir descended
upon the hardest hit areas. Also came tens of thousands
of troops from Gujranwala and Kharian. They quite
naturally had no idea of the locality, the terrain,
or the people. They could not begin to differentiate
between the genuinely needy and the greedy, between
the ones in despair and those exploiting. They did
their best, without local support, but distribution
of relief goods was haphazard. Tens of thousands of
Kashmiri government officials have survived the earthquake.
With most schools destroyed, thousands of teachers
are also available, ready and able, to support the
operations. They know the children. They know the
families. They are close to the ground. They are well
respected in the community. Yet they continue to remain
on the sidelines, their invaluable knowledge being
put to no use. Unless the local community is involved,
the needy will be ignored and lives will be lost.
Similarly, in the interim period the local community
can help enormously in guiding the administration
in setting up and running tent villages effectively,
according to local needs.
The final phase of
reconstruction is where it can get murky. Reconstruction
concerns Kashmir. It must be "of Kashmiris, by
Kashmiris, for Kashmiris". The Army's
Engineer-in-Chief has been named to head the reconstruction
effort. Fair enough, although it should have been
a Kashmiri.He must now be based in Muzzafarabad. Everyone
involved in reconstructing Kashmir should be in Kashmir,
not Islamabad, not Rawalpindi. That alone will clearly
show the intent. Billions of dollars will be spent
in Kashmir every year for many years. Kashmiris must
have a decisive say in how the money is spent, what
is built and where. Planning, execution and oversight
bodies must all be under the effective control of
Kashmiris. All contracts must go to Kashmiri companies
and contractors, who can always hire Pakistani and
foreign expertise. And the right signals must go out
now, We do not want to flood Kashmir with the Punjabi
land mafia and its Islamabad sponsors. And we can
just as easily do without a new lot of local Haliburtons
emerging, which will surely happen if Islamabad, not
Kashmir, calls the shots. The victims are Kashmiris.
The beneficiaries must also be Kashmiris.
Once the first aid
phase is over and the interim phase begins, Kashmiris
should be hired to replace soldiers who can go back
to their units, leaving only essential military supervision,engineering
and medical teams behind. It will enable tens of thousands
of Kashmiris who have lost their livelihoods, to earn
a fair wage. This will help restore their dignity
and is vital for the self-esteem of a proud and traumatized
people. Job opportunities have to be created to replace
aid dependence.
All of the above may well be obvious. What may not
be obvious is that the term Kashmiris should not be
limited to Azad Kashmiris.
The earthquake gives
us an opportunity to pause and reflect. The Line of
Control was irrelevant when terror struck. The past
has been terrible for the people on both sides of
the Line, with more deaths resulting from militant
operations than from the earthquake. A lot of progress
is now being made in the on-going India-Pakistan dialogue.
Perhaps it is time to build dramatically upon it.
The massive reconstruction program of Kashmir will
shape the entire region for the 21st Century, bringing
newfound prosperity to an impoverished region. Peace
is a prerequisite for reconstruction and prosperity.
Its beneficiaries must be all Kashmiris. After all,
it is everybody's dream that Kashmir will be united
one day.
Outlandish though
it may seem, the Reconstruction Authority should be
given some leeway to interact with the leadership
of occupied Kashmir, and perhaps involve them in the
reconstruction of Azad Kashmir. Indeed, the Kashmiri
community overseas should also be involved, as they
are important stakeholders. It will not compromise
our security, nor alter our principled stand, but
it could well be the most bold and dramatic confidence-building
measure in the India-Pakistan dialogue. After all,
the dream of changing the geography alone is not enough;
more important is to change the mindset. The first
steps should be taken today.
|